Mrs. Poe Book Review-How Much of it is Real?

Who In The World Is Mrs. Poe? Lynn Cullen Knows

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. See the disclaimer for more details.

Mrs. Poe book cover-by Lynn Cullen
  • Mrs. Poe
  • Lynn Cullen
  • Historical Fiction
  • Gallery Books
  • April 1, 2014
  • Paperback
  • 352 pages

This novel of historical fiction by Lynn Cullen is a captivating depiction of an affair between Edgar Allen Poe (Mr. Poe) and Mrs. Osgood. Told from Mrs. Osgood’s point of view we get a look into the years 1845-1847. Just after Mr. Poe’s successful publishing of “The Raven” does the affair between the two poets begin. Mrs. Osgood must decide if her love for Mr. Poe is worth ruining her reputation all while maintaining a friendship with Mrs. Poe, her children, and dealing with her own twisted marriage.

What Was The Best Part Of This Novel?

In this book review of Mrs. Poe, I wanted to focus on the characters. This is because the characters are what made this book.

Each one was so different and they added to the book in a way another character could not. Some of the real-life characters may be people you have heard about, others not so much. I don’t like to keep all of my book reviews under one particular format.

Rather, I like to focus on what I view as the most important aspects of the book that I have read. Essentially, I write about what I think you should know. For my Mrs. Poe book review, that happens to be the characters that Lynn Cullen researched and created in her novel. She kept them varied and realistic. She made me curious about each person and how they must have been in real life. Keep reading to see how.

Mr. & Mrs. Osgood

Mrs. osgood-purple shelf club

I promise there are no spoilers! Mr. Osgood is a painter and Mrs. Osgood is a poet. Mrs. Osgood almost immediately dispels the nature of her marriage and even gives a little backstory on the two.

While she loved him in the beginning, as a reader you can tell she no longer feels the way she once did. If there were no repercussions, I feel that she would have left him ages ago. And for good reason too!

Mr. Osgood-purple shelf club

Mrs. Poe as a character does not make the best decisions all the time, but there is a likability to her that makes you root for her happiness. No matter how likable she is, the book showcases her struggle of choosing love and social suicide or staying married to Mr. Osgood and building up her career as a poet. It makes me wonder what I would have done had I been in her shoes.

I would not say such kind words about Mr. Osgood. There is not much good to say about him other than he is great with word choice and he must have been a wonderful painter during that time. I do wish that the author had added some likable characteristics to him.

It is evident that Mr. Osgood loves his wife and children but it is equally evident that they are not his priority. I found myself more supportive of the affair between Mr. Poe and Mrs. Osgood because of Mr. Osgood’s actions. Love changes the rules and while reading this book I could see this clear as day.

Mr. & Mrs. Poe

”Edgar allen poe-purple shelf club

My word this is a difficult relationship to digest! Edgar Allen Poe is as famous today for his poems and storytelling as he was after “The Raven” was published. I found myself learning so much more about him than what I knew prior to reading this novel.

Lynn Cullen writes of him in a way that is both terrifying and captivating. Many characters in the book view him in a way I think many of us today picture him being. He is incredibly witty and has perfect, intellectual comebacks.

I found myself laughing many times at the remarks he made to people. However, another side of him is revealed. I would strike him almost as a hopeless romantic. I know, very surprising! The more I read the book the more I wanted to jump in a time machine and find out for myself.

Mrs. poe-purple shelf club

Mrs. Poe is lesser well-known as she rarely leaves the house due to an illness that is masqueraded as bronchitis. Later you will find out that this is not the case. She is rather child-like and possessive but the further into the book I got the more I sympathized with her.

She is much more intuitive than she lets on as well. Mr. Poe is very loving and caring toward her but he does not love her in a romantic sort of way. The two have known each other since childhood and the bits and pieces that were revealed made me so badly want to read a story about their life prior to this novel; if only to know and understand their relationship more.


Historical Fiction Meets Thriller Meets Romance

There is so much packed into the novel, Mrs. Poe. Your heart will ache, you’ll want to speak up for characters when they can not speak for themselves, you will laugh, feel frustrated, and at times you will feel puzzled.

I love a book that makes me think and one that shocks me. I am telling you now that there are some side characters that you will think you know, but you don’t. If you love romance then you will be captivated by Mr. Poes’ words and stolen moments with Mrs. Osgood.

If you love historical fiction like me, then I guarantee this book is for you. Any movie that is based in the 1800s I will watch, no questions asked. I only wish there was a movie version of this book.

I was surprised by one particular scene in this book. The importance behind the scene prevents me from telling you what happened so you will just have to read it for yourself. What I can tell you is that it had a thriller vibe to it that kept my eyes glued to the pages. It was almost as if Edgar Allen Poe had worked with Lynn Cullen to write out this scene. My mind was blown as I had not seen it coming…at all!

Book Review Rating and What I was Dying to Know

Mrs. Poe is a novel that sent me through a whirlwind of emotions. For this reason, I have to give it a 5-star rating. When I am writing a book review, I give the star rating based on what parts of the book I liked and disliked, and I pay attention to how captivating the book is. I believe my book review is the tell all of Mrs. Poe (without the spoilers).

During and after reading this book I am dying to know how much of it is real and how much of it is actually fiction. The author states that she researched the affair between Mr. Poe and Mrs. Osgood. I liken it to when you watch a movie that says it’s based on a true story and then once you’ve finished watching you look it up to see how real it is. Now, I want to do the same, if only to know what really happened.

Let’s Talk About It

Just as I am dying to know more about the novel, Mrs. Poe, I am dying to know more about what you guys think! Tell me, have you read the book before? If you haven’t, do you want to? Do you think Edgar Allen Poe could possibly have been a hopeless romantic? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below!

If you like historical fiction, romance, thrillers, or even gossip, then this is the book for you.

Check out my other review of The Witcher: Blood of Elves!

With Love,

Alexis

It has been so great talking to you. If you like what I have to say, you can support me by:

  • Subscribing to my newsletter. (P.S. you will get access to my VIP Freebies Vault if you do)
  • Clicking and buying through my affiliate links. The cost does not change for you, but I do get a small commission from your purchase.
  • Leaving a comment below or contacting me via my contact page for any requests or just to talk.

If you are an author, let’s support each other! I have services that I can provide to you via my services page Or, you can contact me here about doing a book review, book cover reveal, book blog tour, and more!

10 thoughts on “Who In The World Is Mrs. Poe? Lynn Cullen Knows”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.